News: What is the latest AAAS news?
Journalists Shift Focus to Impacts of Climate Change
CHICAGO--Alarming stories about stranded polar bears and swamped coasts
are bound to stay in the headlines, but journalists covering the
climate crisis are starting to write less about dramatic research
findings and more about the impacts of climate change, according to
speakers in a seminar at the 2009 AAAS Annual Meeting.
The new
stories require a healthy dose of political and economic
reporting, but that doesn't mean that science journalists should be
willing to turn over their beat to less specialized reporters, the
panelists agreed.
"Science journalists shouldn't give up their
hold on the issue...because the policy solutions will also have to be
critically tested," by the scientific community, said Pallab Ghosh,
a science correspondent for BBC News.
When general beat
reporters are assigned to climate change stories, they often bring a
"political style, kind of a Ph.D. A versus Ph.D. B style" to
their coverage, which can lead to "massive distortion" of nuanced
climate findings, said Steven Schneider, Ph.D., a Stanford University
climatologist who has worked extensively on climate policy and public
outreach.
The participants in the symposium, "Hot and Hotter:
Media Coverage of Climate-Change Impacts, Policies, and Politics,"
agreed that climate change reporting may be challenging in the near
future, as public interest shifts toward the economic crisis and the
news industry itself experiences its own sea change.
Climate change reporting "made the hit parade" in 2007 with the release of the fourth assessment report
from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), but has
since "evened out" said Cristine Russell, a senior fellow at
Harvard's Belfer Center of Science and International Affairs.
In
an era of shrinking circulation and plagarism scandals in traditional
media, "it's not clear whether we can regain respect at a time
when we most need it to report on a critical issue like climate
change," said veteran science journalist Bud Ward of the Yale Forum on
Climate Change and the Media.
The
dismantling of traditional
news platforms in favor of blogs and Twitter means that journalists
"are going to need expert mentors" from the science community as they
write their stories, since seasoned science reporters are becoming
scarce in the newsroom, Ward
cautioned.
Ward and his colleague Peter Spotts of the Christian Science Monitor agreed that climate reporting will follow the same "hyper-local" focus adopted by newspapers across the country.
"Journalists
need to be writing about how much, how fast, and how will it affect
me--not just the global average 'me,' but the me in Phoenix, in London,
in New Delhi, and in South Africa,"
said Spotts.
said Spotts.
"The challenge, frankly, is to avoid becoming so bummed by the
science that you become cynical about the policy objectives," Spotts joked.
But
he also noted that several of the political analysts he had talked to
since the election of U.S. President Barack Obama "are more hopeful now
that major climate climate legislation will move through at least the
U.S. House of Representatives" by the end of the year.

